Thieving: choose loot by the material you need
Targets have different loot, requirements and risk. Use the item you need to choose a target rather than assuming every success pays the same reward.
Version: EA launch documents 2026-11-17; client build unverified
Before you start
- Melvor Idle 2 Steam Early Access; meet the requirements shown for your action.
Steps
- Find the desired material in a named target loot table, then check the target level and access requirements.
- Inspect any tool requirement as well as the level. A chest can require a lockpick or an alternative key condition.
- Observe an initial session and check the actual loot and health outcome. A table entry is a possible reward, not a promise for each action.
- Return the materials to their destination recipe; compare spare loot by its known uses before selling it.
Success: The desired material has actually dropped; target eligibility and health are checked before continuing.
A concrete feather candidate
Locked Ranchers Chest includes Feathers in its common loot table. The studied record has Thieving level 33 and additional tool/key conditions; it is not an immediate no-requirement answer for a new character.
Leave rate claims out until calculated
Success, damage, downtime and loot weights affect the result. A long loot list does not establish profit per hour.
Citizen
Thieving 1; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Stone, Bread. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Thug
Thieving 5; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Leather Boots, Leather Vambraces, Leather Cowl, Leather Chaps, Leather Body. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Locked Thug Chest
Thieving 10; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Uncut Topaz, Silver Bar, Iron Dagger, Hard Leather Boots, Rope. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Cooking Stall
Thieving 12; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Wheat, Bread, Flour, Milk, Cheese. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Thug Chief
Thieving 15; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Copper Gloves, Copper Helmet, Copper Mallet, Copper Platebody, Lockpick. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Craftsman
Thieving 17; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Clay, Bucket of Sand, Bucket of Water, Pack of Vials, String. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Fisherman
Thieving 20; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Basic Bait, Raw Shrimp, Raw Sardine, Raw Herring, Raw Perch. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Farmer
Thieving 25; inputs: gathering/loot action; see access and supply conditions; base products: loot pool: Potato, Onion, Lettuce, Wheat, Garlic. Loot entries are possible rewards, not a full guaranteed payout; check tools and access separately.
Scope of the examples
These are selected low-requirement data records, not a full unlock list or fastest-training route. Quest-gated and alternative-condition entries are omitted from this introductory list. Availability still depends on the current game.
Version and verification
Data examples use the community snapshot labelled EA build 26724394. These examples have not been tested in the current game client. October Demo interface references are labelled separately. No fastest-training, safe-idle or measured-profit claim is made.